Home · Journal · How to read a rare-book condition report
JournalHow to read a rare-book condition report
Every serious bookseller describes a book twice: once with a grade, and once with a list of what is wrong with it. The grade is a summary; the list is the evidence. Learning to read both is the single most useful skill a collector can have.
The grading ladder
The trade in the English-speaking world uses a short ladder of terms, and dealers try to apply them consistently even though no two copies are alike.
- Fine. As close to new as an old book can be. No defects of any kind, or none that a careful eye would find. For a book printed two centuries ago this is rare, and the word should be read literally.
- Near Fine. A bright, clean, tight copy with one or two very minor faults that the description will name: a touch of rubbing at the extremities, a faint bookplate shadow, a previous owner's neat name.
- Very Good. A sound, attractive, complete copy showing ordinary signs of age and handling. This is the honest middle of the market, and a Very Good copy of a scarce book is usually a better buy than a Fine copy of a common one.
- Good. Complete and usable but with obvious wear, which the report must spell out. "Good" in bookselling means below average, which surprises people reading the word for the first time.
- Fair and Poor. Worn, perhaps incomplete, and kept mainly as reading copies or for their plates. Reputable dealers say so plainly.
Many booksellers grade the binding and the dust jacket separately ("Very Good in a Good jacket"), because a jacket is paper and ages faster than cloth or leather.
The vocabulary of defects
After the grade comes a list of faults. These are the terms you will meet most often, and what they mean in practice.
- Foxing. Small brown or rust-coloured spots in the paper, caused by impurities in the sheet reacting with humidity over time. Light foxing is normal in nineteenth-century books; heavy foxing that obscures text is a serious fault.
- Toning or browning. An overall darkening of the paper, common in books printed on cheap wood-pulp stock after about 1870.
- Rubbing. Surface wear to leather or cloth, usually at the corners, joints and spine ends, where a book is handled and shelved. Rubbed is expected on old leather; "rubbed through" means the surface layer is gone.
- Cocked or rolled spine. The text block has leaned so the book no longer sits square. Often caused by a book being read lying open or stored at an angle. Cosmetic in mild cases, structural in bad ones.
- Cracked hinge or joint. The hinge is inside the book, where the endpaper meets the text block; the joint is the outside groove of the binding. "Hinges cracked" means the book is weakening where the cover meets the spine; "joints split" means the cover is detaching.
- Chipped. Small pieces missing from the edge of a dust jacket or the head and tail of a leather spine.
- Dampstain or tidemark. A stain with a visible edge where water once reached. Dealers should say where it is and how far it extends into the text.
- Worming. Tunnels or pinholes left by insect larvae, found in older books. A few holes in the margin are tolerated in early printed books; holes through text are noted and priced accordingly.
- Offsetting. Ink or colour from a plate or newspaper clipping transferred to the facing page.
- Bumped. A corner or spine end has been knocked and the board beneath is dented or softened.
- Sunned or faded. The spine or a board has lost colour through light exposure. Very common on cloth bindings that stood on a shelf facing a window.
- Rebacked or recased. The book has been repaired: a new spine fitted over the original boards, or the text block reattached to its covers. Good repairs are legitimate and should always be disclosed.
- Ex-library. The copy once belonged to a lending or institutional library and carries stamps, pockets or labels. This lowers value considerably for most collectors.
Completeness is separate from condition
A book can be Fine and still lack a map, a plate or a half-title. Careful dealers check their copies against a bibliography and state whether all the plates called for are present, and they say so if a leaf has been supplied from another copy. When a description is silent on completeness for an illustrated book, it is fair to ask.
How to use the report
Read the defect list before the grade, and ask whether each defect matters to you. A reader may not mind a sunned spine; a collector building a shelf of bright copies will. A cracked hinge on a cheap book is a cost; on an important one it is a reason to budget for a binder. The grade tells you where the book sits on the ladder; the defects tell you why, and whether the price is right.
If anything in one of our descriptions is unclear, every record on this site carries an enquiry form, and we will send more photographs or a fuller report on request. For examples of the grades in practice, browse the fine bindings and sets or the literature and poetry shelves.