Home · Journal · Fore-edge paintings: what they are and how to spot a good one
JournalFore-edge paintings: what they are and how to spot a good one
Close a fore-edge painted book and you see only gilt. Fan the pages slightly and a landscape, a portrait or a scene from the text appears across the edge of the leaves. It is one of the few genuine surprises left in bookselling, and one of the most frequently misunderstood.
How a fore-edge painting is made
The fore-edge is the long edge of the text block opposite the spine. To paint it, a binder clamps the book with the pages fanned a few degrees, so that a sliver of each leaf is exposed. A watercolour is painted across those slivers. The book is then released, the edge is squared up and gilded (or, less often, marbled) in the ordinary way. Closed, the gilt hides everything; fanned, the gilt vanishes and the painting shows. Because the paint lies on the extreme margin of each page, it never touches the text.
A double fore-edge carries two different scenes, one visible when the pages are fanned one way and another when fanned the other. Rarer still are books painted on all three edges, or with a second painting hidden beneath the first.
A short history
Decorated edges are old; painted edges that disappear under gilt are usually dated to the late seventeenth century in England, and the technique is associated above all with the Edwards family of Halifax, binders working from the 1780s. Through the early nineteenth century the fashion spread to London binders and to the owners of devotional books, poetry and travel accounts, which were natural subjects for a small landscape. The practice never entirely stopped, and that is the first thing a buyer needs to understand.
Period, later and modern
The trade distinguishes three broad groups, and prices follow them.
- Period or contemporary paintings were done at or near the time the book was bound, most often between about 1780 and 1850. They are the scarcest and the most valuable, especially when the subject relates to the text and the binding is untouched.
- Later paintings were added to older books, often in the late nineteenth or twentieth century, to make an ordinary volume more saleable. Many are skilful. Honest dealers describe them as "later" and price them as decorated books rather than as period artefacts.
- Modern paintings, from the twentieth century to the present, are a living craft. Some artists sign their work on the edge; many do not. They can be charming and are collected in their own right, but they should never be sold as antique.
What to look for
There is no laboratory test a buyer can run at a bookshop counter, but a few observations will take you a long way.
- Does the gilding sit over the paint, or the paint over the gilding? In a properly executed painting the gilt was applied after the painting, so the edge looks uniformly gilt when closed. If flecks of colour show through on the closed edge, or the gilt looks disturbed, the painting may have been added after gilding.
- Does the subject fit the book? A view of Bath on a Bath guidebook, a hunting scene on a sporting work, a church on a prayer book: these are the natural pairings of period work. A generic landscape on a volume of sermons is more often a later addition, though not always.
- Is the binding of the right date and undisturbed? A fore-edge painting on a book that has been rebound later than the painting's supposed date cannot be period. Look at the leather, the tooling and the endpapers together.
- Is the painting consistent with wear? Period paintings on books that have been read for a century and a half usually show some softening, a little loss where the edge has been handled, and toning that matches the paper. A crisp, bright painting on a worn book deserves a second look.
- Quality of execution. The best work has real draughtsmanship, confident perspective and a palette that reads clearly in a few millimetres of exposed paper. Fuzzy, over-worked paintings are usually later and usually cheaper.
- Documentation. Provenance, an old bookseller's description, or a binder's ticket for a known fore-edge workshop all add weight. Absence of documentation is normal and not damning.
Condition and care
A fore-edge painting is watercolour on paper and should be treated as such. Keep the book out of direct light, do not fan it more than needed to show the picture, and never let a prospective buyer "test" the edge with a wet finger. When photographing one, fan the pages gently against a dark cloth and let the gilt go dull; the picture will appear.
We describe each painting on this site with its apparent date, its subject and its relation to the text, and we say plainly when we believe the work to be later than the binding. Those currently on the shelves are gathered in the fore-edge paintings category; related decorated bindings sit with the fine bindings and sets.